Workplace Wellness Strategy

Designing team wellness challenges

Check Your Wellness Program ROI
How much can a Wellness Program save you ?
Eligible Employees (slide to adjust)
500 employees
Average Salary (slide to adjust)
$60,000
$ XXX,679
Your Savings Potential with a Wellness Program
Find My ROI Breakdown

Table of Contents

Most wellness programs measure whether an individual signed up. But the difference between a challenge that runs three weeks and one that becomes a habit can sit in the social structure, not just the individual or the incentive.

Samantha Levin, Wellness Program Manager at Wellness360, explains what group formats do to participation and where team design quietly excludes people.

Why collaboration outlasts competition

Collaboration produces better sustained behavior, and it’s no contest. Competition gets a spike early on, then people drop off in the middle because they’re not winning. Collaboration works because it taps into something more basic. People want to feel connected and part of something, not just ranked against each other.

It also spreads the load. When someone has a rough week, the team absorbs it instead of that person falling off. Most real progress needs more than one kind of strength anyway, so leaning on each other tends to get people further than trying to outperform everyone.

When a client moves the same challenge from an individual format to a team format, completion usually goes up, and it’s not subtle. The individual format has a natural drop off partway through. The team format pushes past that, because no one wants to be the one who stops logging when other people are watching. What really changes underneath is the question people are answering. On their own, it’s how do I get through this. On a team, it becomes how do we get through this together, and that second question keeps people showing up longer and logging more.

The clearest first week signal is whether anyone posts in the group chat or team thread early on. If no one says anything, the team can go quiet fast. Samantha has watched teams go silent immediately after kickoff and never recover. Silence in week one is basically the whole prediction.

The people who never join a team are a meaningful chunk of the population, and that holds steady across clients. What actually moves some of them is a small team of two or three people instead of a big group of 10 to 15. Big teams feel like performance. Small teams feel manageable and make it easier to connect with the individuals in the group.

Where can group structure help

Group structure works well for sleep or step challenges. They’re low stakes and easy to talk about. It backfires with mental health. The moment group visibility goes on something someone is genuinely struggling with, it builds a reason for them to hide it instead of getting the help they need. Shared accountability is powerful, but it’s not a universal fix. It comes down to how vulnerable the topic is and whether the goal can be measured without exposing someone.

What makes or breaks a challenge is whether the manager participates. Within the same company, one team where the manager logs their own activity holds together, and another where the manager forwards the sign up emails and disappears falls apart quickly. It comes down to trust and clear direction versus micromanaging or going quiet.

The managers who make it work set clear expectations up front, give their team room to run with it instead of hovering, keep checking in along the way instead of only showing up when something’s wrong, and deal with friction early instead of letting it sit. That builds collaboration and meaningful participation. A manager who doesn’t participate can also create resentment, with employees asking why they have to do this if the manager doesn’t.

Trust, cheating and fair rewards

The worst version of cheating is someone manually inflating their numbers well past what’s realistic, with other teams noticing before the program team did. The program recovered once the client added a simple verification step and communicated it openly instead of quietly changing the rules. Trust came back faster than expected once people saw it was being taken seriously.

When financial rewards are attached to team targets, tie the reward to individual participation within the team goal, not to the team hitting the number as a whole. Samantha has asked clients to restructure rewards that were originally all or nothing for the group, because no one should lose money because a teammate had a rough month.

What to measure instead of participation

Participation doesn’t mean much on its own. Everyone reports it because it’s easy to pull, but a high sign up number with no one finishing anything isn’t success. It’s just a good email subject line.

A better measure is whether an individual comes back every time and actually participates: asking questions, pulling resources and saving them, watching the video all the way through, not coming once and leaving.

For a CFO, report completion rate rather than sign up rate, retention into a second or third challenge, and, if it’s tracked, a health metric tied to the challenge that is sustained after the challenge ends, not just during it. Retention is a huge piece of it: people coming back and completing the challenge, not just signing up and logging nothing.

Your Workforce Is Your Greatest Asset

Ensure they remain healthy and happy with
Wellness360.